Has social media become a digital circus for wildlife?
Amateur MMA fighter Cole Johnson recently attracted attention after a PR stunt claiming he could defeat a chimpanzee.
His announcement sparked a flurry of posts, with content creators debating whether he could win, photoshopped memes showing chimpanzees in boxing gear, and AI-generated posters promoting the matchup.
The supposed fight was later reported to be a hoax. But even a fake fight raises real concerns about how we portray and treat wildlife. Dr Itai Roffman, co-executive director of the Jane Goodall Institute Israel, condemned the announcement and warned that its spread could encourage copycat spectacles, even if the original claim was fabricated.
The use of chimpanzees for human entertainment has a long history in circuses, on film sets and in music videos. Social media offers another stage, where animals can be made into props and punchlines for views. Has the circus simply moved into our feeds?
The Jane Goodall Institute’s imagery guidelines for great apes explain why these portrayals matter. Great apes should never be used as performers or selfie props, dressed in human clothing or forced into unnatural activities for our amusement. What looks funny to a viewer may conceal fear, stress or suffering.
These images also shape how we understand wildlife. A study of chimpanzees in advertising found that viewers shown entertainment commercials had a poorer understanding of chimpanzees’ conservation status and unsuitability as pets than viewers shown footage of natural behaviour. They were also less likely to donate to conservation.
Showing great apes as pets, performers or props risks making their exploitation seem ordinary and normalised. JGI warns that inappropriate imagery can also encourage demand for pet apes and close encounters, fuelling illegal wildlife trade.
JGI’s statement on ape rights calls for respect for apes’ lives, freedom from unnecessary suffering, opportunities to make choices, and environments where they can express natural behaviour and live with compatible companions. These principles should guide how we portray our great ape cousins online.
AI-generated content adds another challenge. The matchup posters and boxing memes gave an imagined encounter a visual presence. Viewers may struggle to distinguish genuine photographs from edited or generated images. A fabricated picture does not prove that an animal was harmed, but it can still encourage audiences to see wildlife as something to dominate or ridicule.
The Social Media Animal Cruelty Coalition (SMACC) highlights how animals suffer for content made to entertain and attract attention. Its guidance on AI-generated cruelty warns that synthetic imagery can normalise violence, desensitise viewers and undermine understanding of animal welfare, even when no real animal appears.
We can all help change what fills our feeds:
- Pause before sharing. Consider what an image suggests about an animal’s needs and place in the world.
- Report harmful content. SMACC advises against sharing or engaging with cruelty content, even to express outrage, because this can increase its reach.
- Share respectful images. Choose content showing natural behaviour and appropriate care, with clear context where needed.
Social media can help people understand and protect wildlife. Every time we post or share, we have an opportunity to support that purpose. Chimpanzees deserve respect and the freedom to live as chimpanzees, beyond any role we invent for our entertainment.
Read Dr Roffman’s full statement below:
“JGI Israel condemns amateur MMA fighter Cole Johnson’s public announcement that he will wrestle an adult male chimpanzee in a ring. Even if this online Facebook post is fabrication, the fact that it went viral on social media is detrimental to the fate of chimpanzees (and potentially gorillas and orangutans), encouraging copycat spectacles of illegally kept critically endangered species. His openly violent and abusive language that he will “slam and bite the chimpanzee” is morally incomprehensible and incites violence and bodily harm to a helpless captive chimpanzee.
These bushmeat orphans had their family members brutally murdered in the wild for every infant smuggled into global trading markets by criminal syndicates. Such barbaric blood sports were common in the Roman Empire gladiator battles of over 2,000 years ago with wildlife – that resulted in the complete or regional extinction of the Barbary lions, Asian lions, Moroccan Bears, Syrian Brown bears, Syrian ostrich, East Asia crocodiles, North African and Asiatic cheetahs, Arabian leopards etc. We must stop this abusive exploitation from occurring again. However, such Great Ape Hominid wrestling matches were known in the past few years to take place in circuses and pseudo-zoos in Thailand.
Chimpanzees are our sister-species, have cultural diversity in the wilds of Africa and by normalizing the illegal wildlife trafficking even in underground social circles will cause their extinction and with it our prehistoric cultural heritage (including that of our cousin species the gorillas and orangutans). There is urgent need to file an official compliant with Facebook, identify the location of such an event and the supplier/holder of the chimpanzee. In order for him to be confiscated by authorities and sent to an accredited sanctuary. Illegal wildlife trafficking is connected to human, drug, and weapons trafficking with the same criminal organizations running the sales along shared trading routes. This violence must end.”
Dr. Itai Roffman
Senior researcher/lecturer co-executive director, The Jane Goodall Institute Israel, Max Stern Yezreel Valley College
Imagery credit: JGI / Stephano Lihedule
